My Photo

Recent Posts

May 2008

Sun Mon Tue Wed Thu Fri Sat
        1 2 3
4 5 6 7 8 9 10
11 12 13 14 15 16 17
18 19 20 21 22 23 24
25 26 27 28 29 30 31

I Recommend:


  • Get Firefox!

Bottom of the Page


  • Listed on Blogwise

  • Blogarama - The Blog Directory

  • Blogdex - The Weblog Diffusion Index


  • Globe of Blogs
Blog powered by TypePad

« Our Eyes Off the Ball | Main | No Confidence in Berkeley Study II »

November 20, 2004

No Confidence in Berkeley Study

This will be a brief post on the debate over the "missing" 130,000+ votes in Florida.  There will be more to come from me before the weekend is done, in particular an attempt to sort out the competing claims from the gearheads, I hope in language that the non-gearheads appreciate.

The much-discussed Berkeley study which reaches this conclusion has some methodological problems which ought to make us quite cautious.  For now, I will make only one simple point.  Take a look at Tables 2-6 and then look at Figure 1.  See anything missing from the graph?  Here's a hint: These are estimates and not certainties.

As Stats 101 will tell you, an estimate contains error.  A poll, for instance, will have a margin of error of, say, plus or minus about 3% with a sample size of 1,000.  That is, with 95% certainty, the population proportion will be within 3% above or 3% below the sample's proportion.

So, what is the 95% confidence interval for the point prediction the Berkeley team makes that 130,733 votes  "disappeared" from Kerry's column?  They don't tell us.  In other words, we do not know whether, at any reasonable level of confidence, the electronic and optical scan methods really did produce substantively meaningful differences.

Moreover, when graphing the estimated effects as they do in Figure 1, the confidence interval will be wider -- that is to say, more uncertain -- the closer one gets to the tails of the distribution (one end of the sample or the other).  Recall that nearly all of the power of their conclusion comes from the three large Dem-leaning counties on the far right of the graph.  In other words, the counties that are closer to the fat part of the (for now invisible) confidence interval.  Indeed, except for that end of the distribution, the two voting methods track very closely.  This makes their lack of attention to the confidence interval all the more troubling.

At a minimum, this is a shoddy way to report statistical results.  Worse, the interpretation may be downright misleading without taking into account the confidence interval.  They are advertising an estimate as certainty.  It's just a matter of basic statistics.  Let's not overhype it until they show their work.

TrackBack

TrackBack URL for this entry:
http://www.typepad.com/t/trackback/196764/1438937

Listed below are links to weblogs that reference No Confidence in Berkeley Study:

» Berkeley researchers: "Irregularities May Have Awarded 130,000 - 260,000 or More Excess Votes to Bush" from The Command Post - 2004 US Presidential Election
From their press release: Today the University of California’s Berkeley Quantitative Methods Research Team released a statistical study - the sole method available to monitor the accuracy of e-voting - reporting irregularities associated with ele... [Read More]

Comments

herbals@drugs.com

herbals@drugs.com

herbals@drugs.com

herbals@drugs.com

herbals@drugs.com

herbals@drugs.com

herbals@drugs.com

herbals@drugs.com

herbals@drugs.com

herbals@drugs.com

herbals@drugs.com

herbals@drugs.com

herbals@drugs.com

herbals@drugs.com

herbals@drugs.com

herbals@drugs.com

xxx real home sex movies [url=http://xxx-amature-movies.xxxpornuga.info/xxx-real-home-sex-movies.html]xxx real home sex movies[/url] http://xxx-amature-movies.xxxpornuga.info/xxx-real-home-sex-movies.html euro group sex party [url=http://group-sex-mmf.xxxpornuga.info/euro-group-sex-party.html]euro group sex party[/url] http://group-sex-mmf.xxxpornuga.info/euro-group-sex-party.html free amateur sex photos [url=http://amateur-sex-shows.xxxpornuga.info/free-amateur-sex-photos.html]free amateur sex photos[/url] http://amateur-sex-shows.xxxpornuga.info/free-amateur-sex-photos.html how big is john holmes penis [url=http://big-penis-holes.xxxpornuga.info/how-big-is-john-holmes-penis.html]how big is john holmes penis[/url] http://big-penis-holes.xxxpornuga.info/how-big-is-john-holmes-penis.html teen sex stars [url=http://teen-hitchhiker-sex.xxxpornuga.info/teen-sex-stars.html]teen sex stars[/url] http://teen-hitchhiker-sex.xxxpornuga.info/teen-sex-stars.html

simple weight loss [url=http://simple-weight-loss.firstbigloan.info/]simple weight loss[/url] http://simple-weight-loss.firstbigloan.info/ online physician prescriptions [url=http://online-prescriptions.bestbigbrand.info/online-physician-prescriptions.html]online physician prescriptions[/url] http://online-prescriptions.bestbigbrand.info/online-physician-prescriptions.html internet online gambling australia [url=http://harrahs-online-gambling.greatpowersupply.info/internet-online-gambling-australia.html]internet online gambling australia[/url] http://harrahs-online-gambling.greatpowersupply.info/internet-online-gambling-australia.html category pain relief scale [url=http://relief-breast-pain.topsuperchina.info/category-pain-relief-scale.html]category pain relief scale[/url] http://relief-breast-pain.topsuperchina.info/category-pain-relief-scale.html poker roulette online gambling blackjack [url=http://gambling-online-roulette.greatpowersupply.info/poker-roulette-online-gambling-blackjack.html]poker roulette online gambling blackjack[/url] http://gambling-online-roulette.greatpowersupply.info/poker-roulette-online-gambling-blackjack.html

penis that are big [url=http://big-penis-masturbation.xxxpornuga.info/penis-that-are-big.html]penis that are big[/url] http://big-penis-masturbation.xxxpornuga.info/penis-that-are-big.html hot asian porn sex [url=http://asian-sex-story.xxxpornuga.info/hot-asian-porn-sex.html]hot asian porn sex[/url] http://asian-sex-story.xxxpornuga.info/hot-asian-porn-sex.html mature panty sex [url=http://mature-panty-sex.xxxpornuga.info/]mature panty sex[/url] http://mature-panty-sex.xxxpornuga.info/ big penis peeing [url=http://big-penis.xxxpornuga.info/big-penis-peeing.html]big penis peeing[/url] http://big-penis.xxxpornuga.info/big-penis-peeing.html sex toy woman [url=http://sex-toy-woman.xxxpornuga.info/]sex toy woman[/url] http://sex-toy-woman.xxxpornuga.info/

constipation due to percocet [url=http://percocet-high.ultradevils.com/constipation-due-to-percocet.html]constipation due to percocet[/url] http://percocet-high.ultradevils.com/constipation-due-to-percocet.html teens and adderall [url=http://adderall-inject.ultradevils.com/teens-and-adderall.html]teens and adderall[/url] http://adderall-inject.ultradevils.com/teens-and-adderall.html effexor vs wellbutrin [url=http://effexor-ex.ultradevils.com/effexor-vs-wellbutrin.html]effexor vs wellbutrin[/url] http://effexor-ex.ultradevils.com/effexor-vs-wellbutrin.html 2007 norco [url=http://norco-dosage.ultradevils.com/2007-norco.html]2007 norco[/url] http://norco-dosage.ultradevils.com/2007-norco.html vitamin b acne [url=http://minocyclineacne.ultradevils.com/vitamin-b-acne.html]vitamin b acne[/url] http://minocyclineacne.ultradevils.com/vitamin-b-acne.html

sexy hot and naked chicks [url=http://naked-chicks-wesrling.sexualfuckmafia.com/sexy-hot-and-naked-chicks.html]sexy hot and naked chicks[/url] http://naked-chicks-wesrling.sexualfuckmafia.com/sexy-hot-and-naked-chicks.html tight pussy holes [url=http://tight-pussys.sexualfuckmafia.com/tight-pussy-holes.html]tight pussy holes[/url] http://tight-pussys.sexualfuckmafia.com/tight-pussy-holes.html pussy lips [url=http://pussy-lips.sexualfuckmafia.com/]pussy lips[/url] http://pussy-lips.sexualfuckmafia.com/ girls with tight pussies [url=http://tight-pussy-ass.sexualfuckmafia.com/girls-with-tight-pussies.html]girls with tight pussies[/url] http://tight-pussy-ass.sexualfuckmafia.com/girls-with-tight-pussies.html hardcore chubby chick fucking [url=http://hardcore-lesbos-fucking.pornosexfucking.net/hardcore-chubby-chick-fucking.html]hardcore chubby chick fucking[/url] http://hardcore-lesbos-fucking.pornosexfucking.net/hardcore-chubby-chick-fucking.html

free worldsex hardcore porn [url=http://hardcore-manga-porn.virtualesex.com/free-worldsex-hardcore-porn.html]free worldsex hardcore porn[/url] http://hardcore-manga-porn.virtualesex.com/free-worldsex-hardcore-porn.html hardcore pornstar sex [url=http://hardcore-sex.virtualesex.com/hardcore-pornstar-sex.html]hardcore pornstar sex[/url] http://hardcore-sex.virtualesex.com/hardcore-pornstar-sex.html daphne cartoon sex [url=http://sex-cartoon.pornaneta.net/daphne-cartoon-sex.html]daphne cartoon sex[/url] http://sex-cartoon.pornaneta.net/daphne-cartoon-sex.html super hardcore porn [url=http://porn-hardcore.virtualesex.com/super-hardcore-porn.html]super hardcore porn[/url] http://porn-hardcore.virtualesex.com/super-hardcore-porn.html shaved dildo pussy [url=http://shaved-dildo-pussy.pornaneta.net/]shaved dildo pussy[/url] http://shaved-dildo-pussy.pornaneta.net/

womens small business loans [url=http://business-loans-information.deeprichers.com/womens-small-business-loans.html]womens small business loans[/url] http://business-loans-information.deeprichers.com/womens-small-business-loans.html hsbc business loans [url=http://business-loans.deeprichers.com/hsbc-business-loans.html]hsbc business loans[/url] http://business-loans.deeprichers.com/hsbc-business-loans.html agricultural business loans [url=http://loans-business.deeprichers.com/agricultural-business-loans.html]agricultural business loans[/url] http://loans-business.deeprichers.com/agricultural-business-loans.html business equity loans [url=http://loans-business.deeprichers.com/business-equity-loans.html]business equity loans[/url] http://loans-business.deeprichers.com/business-equity-loans.html advantages of secured loans [url=http://fast-loans-secured.meandmybest.net/advantages-of-secured-loans.html]advantages of secured loans[/url] http://fast-loans-secured.meandmybest.net/advantages-of-secured-loans.html

organic tribal body jewelry [url=http://jewelry-body.surovtsevs.net/organic-tribal-body-jewelry.html]organic tribal body jewelry[/url] http://jewelry-body.surovtsevs.net/organic-tribal-body-jewelry.html estate opal jewelry [url=http://diamond-jewelry.surovtsevs.net/estate-opal-jewelry.html]estate opal jewelry[/url] http://diamond-jewelry.surovtsevs.net/estate-opal-jewelry.html bee jewelry [url=http://ambercelticjewelry.surovtsevs.net/bee-jewelry.html]bee jewelry[/url] http://ambercelticjewelry.surovtsevs.net/bee-jewelry.html diamond jewelry exchange [url=http://diamond-jewelry.surovtsevs.net/diamond-jewelry-exchange.html]diamond jewelry exchange[/url] http://diamond-jewelry.surovtsevs.net/diamond-jewelry-exchange.html body jewelry wholesalers [url=http://navel-jewellery.surovtsevs.net/body-jewelry-wholesalers.html]body jewelry wholesalers[/url] http://navel-jewellery.surovtsevs.net/body-jewelry-wholesalers.html

Hi! Need advice. There is no one else to ask. My credit is bad (very bad) and I am eager to apply for a card. And I have found two variants for me at one website: secured credit cards and unsecured cards for bad credit. I’d like to make the right choice therefore I am searching for advice or experience. And hope that you answer me as soon as possible.

guaranteed approvial credit cards
[url=http://guaranteed-discover-card.buliderscrasd.info]$7000.00 guaranteed credit card[/url]
http://garunteed-approval-credit-credit6817164.bulidersceditcards.info
guaranteed crdeit cards

Some people spend years paying off there credit card debts. That happens because they do not put enough effort in managing their finances and also because they do not read terms and conditions carefully. The information is always there you just need to read it. Just go to any professional credit card site such as
ways to start credit history

There are so many options to choose from when you come to applying for a credit card and have high credit score. I didn't know what's best for me and applied for too many cards I started to forget paying off. But the site that prompted me a way out of debt is
credit cards for those with new credit

my daughter is 17 and currently enrolled at a 4 year university. I want her to apply for a credit card so she would have it for emergencies as she will be away from home. She has no credit, but a part time job. Student cards she applied for said no credit was needed but was denied. Any suggestions if
orchard bank apr rates

I've been running small business for 2 years already and always had a trouble when separating my personal expenses and business ones, as I used one and the same credit card for both. Business credit card solved the problem plus I ordered additional cards for my employees for free, I found the idea at
credit card for 590